As some of you may know, JA Rock and I have
been advised by our publisher to change the title of our Mark Cooper versus America
sequel, which was called Brandon Mills versus Virginity.
Because Amazon would refuse to list it with that title.
When I mentioned this on Goodreads, a few
people pointed me towards this book:
Why is this book allowed to use the V-word, but we
aren’t? I suspect that it’s all to do with the way this book is tagged. While
this book, for all I know, might be full of sexy good times, it’s not listed as
erotica or erotic romance, so it escapes the cull. Here’s how it’s categorised
on Amazon:
Actually, there is a heap of books on
Amazon with the V-word in the title. There are books about this woman:
And this man:
And this product:
And, yes, even virginity exactly as it
pertains to sexual experience, or lack thereof:
The title, if you can’t read it, is Virginity:
A Treasure. Personally an idea I find more disturbing that a lot of
stuff in erotica (yes, even counting monster porn) but that’s a discussion for
another day.
So what’s the big deal about the word
virginity in our title, Amazon? Brandon Mills is nineteen. He’s an adult, who
happens to be a virgin. It’s not unusual. It’s also not unusual for a nineteen
year old college boy to spend a lot of time obsessing about his status.
What’s frustrating about this, as JA
pointed out in an email, is it’s about sex. It’s fairly obvious that Amazon is
only targeting erotica and erotic romance titles. You don’t see the same rules
being enforced on writers of chainsaw blood-splattering gore, do you? And why
should you? It’s ridiculous. Adults have the right to read what they want to
read.
Except, apparently, when it comes to sex.
Then a quick glance at the title – not the content, mind you, but the title
alone – will allow Amazon to make the decision for you. Because there is
absolutely no content in Brandon Mills that crosses any
boundaries. The sex is consensual, and it’s sweet and funny and awkward.
There’s not even any kink in it! Okay, there’s a mild dinosaur fetish, but
that’s kept out of the bedroom.
Here’s what JA wrote in her email, which
sums it up nicely:
I
think the way they're doing it now does come off as an attack on sex. Because I
don't see the same kind of scrutiny being applied to books in the thriller
genre--notorious for exploitative depictions of maimings and murder and sexual
assaults. So why should a romance that depicts those things--as long as it's in
a negative light--be any different?
Come on over here, double standard. Step
into the light so we can all see you.
And, you know what’s most annoying about
this entire thing? The fact that Amazon pretty much owns the universe. What
Amazon wants, Amazon gets. As much as a part of me wants to says “Fuck you,
Amazon!” and publish only to other retailers…well, that would be a pretty dumb
financial decision. Amazon is the
market.
It would just be nice if the market took
its head out of its arse one day soon.
In the meantime, I hope you'll all enjoy Brandon Mills versus the V-Card when it comes out!